Doctors don't get much menopause training. State lawmakers are trying to change that

California Assemblymember Rebecca Bauer-Kahan introduced a measure successful nan existent legislative convention to instruction menopause acquisition for doctors successful nan state. Rich Pedroncelli/AP hide caption

toggle caption

Rich Pedroncelli/AP

Former mediate schoolhouse coach Lorraine Carter Salazar isn't easy embarrassed. But erstwhile she began having basking flashes astatine schoolhouse astir a decade ago, she worried astir really she came disconnected to co-workers, students and parents.

"It doesn't convey competence," said Carter Salazar, 62. She recounted really parents could show she was uncomfortable successful meetings. One time, a student moreover fanned her and remarked that she was utilized to seeing her grandma emotion nan aforesaid way.

When she took her concerns to her doctor, he didn't return them seriously.

"So you sweat," Carter Salazar recalled him saying. "And he's right. Nobody dies from sweating."

People experiencing perimenopause and menopause symptoms — which tin scope from basking flashes and nighttime sweats to temper changes, decreased libido and cognitive issues — often kick of unresponsive doctors and inconsistent care. Symptoms tin effect value of life successful nan moment, and semipermanent health.

Many doctors are ill-equipped to grip these conversations.

Lorraine Carter Salazar (right) useful connected a knitting task astatine a trade group she attends play astatine a Sacramento room branch. Megan Myscofski/CapRadio hide caption

toggle caption

Megan Myscofski/CapRadio

A needs appraisal published in nan aesculapian diary Menopause successful 2023 showed conscionable nether a 3rd of nan residency programs successful obstetrics and gynecology it surveyed offered training connected menopause, moreover though half of nan organization experiences it.

That's led lawmakers successful California and nationally to effort to intervene.

In California, legislators introduced 2 bills this legislative convention connected menopause acquisition for doctors. Assembly Bill 360, which would person required a authorities agency to look into acquisition gaps and really to capable them, was tabled past month. But Assembly Bill 432, which would require menopause coursework for doctors to renew their licenses — if astatine slightest 25% of their patients are women nether 65 — is still moving done nan legislature.

"It reflects my ain acquisition having to spell to 3 doctors earlier a expert could adequately person a speech pinch maine astir menopause," said Democratic Assemblymember Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, who introduced nan measure.

She says erstwhile she was going done menopause, her encephalon fog became truthful aggravated that she worried she mightiness person early-onset Alzheimer's disease.

And California's efforts are portion of a nationalist trend.

"Thirteen states, including California, person introduced a full of 21 bills [related to menopause] this legislative session, which is beautiful stunning really for an rumor that really wasn't connected immoderate legislator's radar, surely 3 years ago," said Jennifer Weiss-Wolf, who runs nan Birnbaum Women's Leadership Center astatine New York University and tracks menopause bills.

Several of those bills besides touch connected expert education. In New Jersey, for example, one measure would allow providers to usage continuing acquisition credits toward their licence renewal. Arizona and Massachusetts introduced bills this twelvemonth to supply much accusation connected menopause to providers and patients.

In caller years, Illinois and Louisiana person started to instruction security sum for immoderate menopause treatments.

Treating symptoms alternatively of letting patients strengthen them

Training is disposable for doctors who want it — and treatments are disposable for group who request them.

"There's nary logic that personification should suffer pinch those symptoms," said Dr. Monica Christmas from nan University of Chicago. She runs nan menopause programme astatine nan Center for Women's Integrated Health.

Christmas, who has practiced gynecology for complete 20 years, fell into nan specialty because her colleagues kept sending her their menopausal patients.

"I didn't cognize nan answers, but I listened," she said.

After proceeding their concerns, she researched their symptoms earlier coming backmost pinch curen ideas. They, successful turn, told their friends astatine work, complete coffee, and while waiting for nan train astir nan expert who took them seriously.

"And truthful very quickly, I sewage ace busy," she said.

Christmas said nan training a schoolhouse offers connected menopause usually depends connected really well-resourced it is. Since fewer schools person a robust program, galore physicians besides activity retired accusation and training elsewhere.

Christmas besides useful for The Menopause Society — a nationalist statement that provides training for doctors connected really to dainty women astatine this shape of life.

Christmas said it's imperative that doctors cognize really to activity pinch tons of different group — because symptoms vary, and truthful do people's tolerance levels and spot successful nan aesculapian system.

"Black women for illustration myself were very reluctant to return thing for nan symptoms that they were experiencing," she said. She ne'er understood why and heard myriad reasons erstwhile she asked. Some patients explained that menopause is simply a earthy process meant to beryllium endured. "Yet, I could spot successful beforehand of maine them having basking flashes successful nan conversation."

Specialized attraction for Black women

Kim Robinson, pinch nan defense statement Black Women for Wellness, said Black women person to navigate discrimination connected apical of seeking adjuvant accusation from wellness attraction providers.

She added that doctors should beryllium amended versed successful really Black women acquisition this clip of life otherwise from different women.

For instance, Black women often acquisition fibroids, aliases benign growths successful nan uterus, astatine higher rates than achromatic women, according to a recent study successful nan American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology.

As they scope menopause, Robinson said many doctors propose Black women get hysterectomy, which is nan removal of nan uterus, without afloat explaining nan risks aliases alternatives. According to nan Mayo Clinic, respective alternatives exist, specified arsenic hormone regulation, but astir 60% of women who person a hysterectomy are offered different curen first.

"It's not conscionable this 1 invasive thing, region your parts and nan problem is solved," she said of nan procedure.

Robinson knows from experience. When her expert suggested she get a hysterectomy, she knew to push backmost and inquire questions, yet uncovering a less-invasive alternative.

But, she said, nan load shouldn't beryllium connected patients to advocator for themselves. Doctors, she said, should get much training and acquisition connected symptoms and treatments.

Challenges to passing a menopause acquisition law 

In California, nan measurement that would require doctors to study menopause builds disconnected a measure that Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed past year. In his veto message, Newsom said nan measure was "too far-reaching" because it would person required wellness security plans to screen costly and non-FDA-approved treatments.

However, Newsom encouraged lawmakers to "continue to activity towards a much tailored solution that tin amended entree to perimenopause and menopause care, pass patients of their options, and promote providers to enactment informed of nan latest objective attraction recommendations," he wrote.

But Bauer-Kahan, nan assemblymember, kept nan provisions that Newsom cited arsenic a problem. However, she added acquisition requirements, erstwhile past year's measure strictly focused connected insurance.

"We've doubled down," she said. "I deliberation 1 of nan things I learned past twelvemonth done nan hearings we held connected menopause and this activity is really small is understood astir menopause."

Newsom's agency declined to remark connected nan measure.

Opposition wrong nan aesculapian section is besides an obstacle.

Dr. Tanya Spirtos, erstwhile president of nan California Medical Association, which represents doctors, said nan measure is well-intentioned but misguided. Doctors mostly cognize they must enactment up to day and informed astir nan latest treatments, she said.

"We do nan reference and nan education, arsenic I say, to enactment 1 measurement up of our patients," she said.

Spirtos, a gynecologist, besides said location are tons of areas — for illustration glucosuria aliases nutrition — wherever doctors request to enactment current, but requiring training successful each 1 would create excessively overmuch of a burden. She said doctors should determine for themselves what benignant of training is astir applicable to their practice.

"Every area that touches connected bones aliases encephalon aliases bosom aliases pussy aliases basking flashes has lit disposable that's really easy for our physicians to get a clasp of and amended themselves," she said.

NYU's Weiss-Wolf's says she hopes to spot entree to bully menopause attraction return off. Her attraction connected women's wellness besides includes advocating for making tampons and pads much accessible.

"Certainly erstwhile I started moving connected periods, group weren't talking astir it successful immoderate benignant of nationalist and systematic way," she said. "And I would opportunity that 10 years later, that feels different to me."

She thinks thing akin is happening now for menopause.

This communicative is portion of a bid produced for nan USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalism's 2025 California Health Equity Fellowship.