Does Georgia's fetal 'personhood' law mean a pregnant woman must stay on life support?

Adriana Smith is simply a diligent astatine Emory University Hospital Midtown successful Atlanta. Emergency complications early successful her gestation led to encephalon death, but she remains connected life support arsenic nan gestation continues, according to her family. Her lawsuit has go a awesome of nan aesculapian and ethical issues stemming from a Georgia rule that bans astir abortions and confers fetal "personhood" rights.
Brynn Anderson/AP hide caption

toggle caption

Brynn Anderson/AP

By nan clip she ended up astatine a Georgia infirmary pinch emergency complications, 30-year-old Atlanta caregiver Adriana Smith was almost 9 weeks pregnant.

Her condition, which included aggregate humor clots, deteriorated arsenic doctors tried to prevention her life, Smith's mother April Newkirk told Atlanta TV position WXIA.

"They did a CT scan and she had humor clots each successful her head. So they had asked maine if they could do a process to relieve them, and I said yes," Newkirk said. "And past they called maine backmost and said that they couldn't do it."

She said doctors declared Smith 'brain dead' and put her connected life support without consulting her.

"It's torture for me," Newkirk said. "I travel present and I spot my girl breathing by nan ventilator, but she's not there."

That was much than 3 months ago. Smith is still pregnant.

"And I'm not saying that we would person chose to terminate her pregnancy," Newkirk said, "but what I'm saying is we should person had a choice."

Except for an emailed statement, Emory Healthcare isn't commenting connected nan case.

"Emory Healthcare uses statement from objective experts, aesculapian literature, and ineligible guidance to support our providers arsenic they make individualized curen recommendations successful compliance pinch Georgia's abortion laws and each different applicable laws," nan connection said. "Our apical priorities proceed to beryllium nan information and wellbeing of nan patients we serve."

Georgia's rule H.B. 481, besides known arsenic nan LIFE Act, passed successful 2019. It went into effect soon aft nan U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade pinch its Dobbs ruling connected June 24, 2022.

The rule bans abortion aft nan constituent astatine which an ultrasound tin observe cardiac activity successful an embryo. Typically this is astir six weeks into pregnancy.

It besides gives Smith's fetus nan aforesaid authorities arsenic a person. The rule says "unborn children are a people of living, chopped persons" and explains that nan authorities of Georgia recognizes "the benefits of providing afloat ineligible nickname to an unborn child."

Did fetal 'personhood' mean life support was required? 

Twenty states now prohibition abortion astatine aliases earlier 18 weeks' gestation; 13 of those person a near-total prohibition connected each abortions pinch very constricted exceptions, according to nan Guttmacher Institute, a nonpartisan investigation group that supports abortion rights.

Like Georgia, immoderate of these states built their abortion restrictions astir nan ineligible conception of 'personhood,' frankincense conferring ineligible authorities and protections connected an embryo aliases fetus during pregnancy.

Smith's lawsuit represents a awesome trial of really this type of rule will beryllium applied successful definite aesculapian situations. Despite being unified successful their guidance to abortion, conservatives and politicians do not ever work together connected nan scope of nan rule successful cases for illustration Smith's.

For example, Georgia's Republican Attorney General Chris Carr doesn't deliberation nan rule restricts nan options successful Smith's care, truthful removing her from life support wouldn't beryllium balanced to aborting nan fetus.

"There is thing successful nan LIFE Act that requires aesculapian professionals to support a female connected life support aft encephalon death. Removing life support is not an action 'with nan intent to terminate a pregnancy,'" Carr said successful a statement.

But Republican Georgia authorities Sen. Ed Setzler, who authored nan LIFE Act, disagrees. Emory's doctors acted appropriately erstwhile they put Smith connected life support, he told the Associated Press.

"I deliberation it is wholly due that nan infirmary do what they tin to prevention nan life of nan child," Setzler told nan AP. "I deliberation this is an different circumstance, but I deliberation it highlights nan worth of guiltless quality life. I deliberation nan infirmary is acting appropriately."

Personhood energizes anti-abortion movement 

"The problem is that Georgia's rule isn't conscionable an abortion ban, it's a 'personhood' rule declaring that a fetus aliases embryo is simply a person, that an 'unborn child,' arsenic nan rule puts it, is simply a person," said Mary Ziegler, a rule professor astatine nan University of California-Davis and writer of "Personhood: The New Civil War complete Reproduction."

The ineligible conception of "personhood" has implications beyond abortion care, specified arsenic nan regularisation of fertility treatment, aliases nan imaginable criminalization of gestation complications for illustration stillbirth and miscarriage.

In Georgia's law, extending authorities of personhood to a fetus changes really kid support is calculated. It besides allows an embryo aliases fetus to beryllium claimed arsenic a limited connected authorities taxes.

But nan thought of personhood is not new, Ziegler said.

"It has been nan extremity for virtually everyone successful nan anti-abortion activity since nan 1960s. That doesn't mean Republicans for illustration that. It doesn't needfully mean that that's what's going to happen. But location is nary daylight betwixt nan anti-abortion activity and nan personhood movement. They're nan same," she said.

The personhood activity has gained much traction since nan Supreme Court's Dobbs ruling successful 2022.

In Alabama, aft nan state's Supreme Court ruled that stiff embryos are people, nan authorities legislature had to measurement successful to let fertility clinics to proceed their work.

"This is benignant of nan early we're looking astatine if we move further successful nan guidance of fetal personhood," Ziegler said. "Any authorities Supreme Court, arsenic we conscionable saw successful Alabama, tin springiness them caller life."

Georgia's rule and gestation outcomes

In Georgia, dozens of OB-GYNs person warned nan authorities rule interferes pinch diligent attraction -- a problem successful a authorities pinch 1 of nan worst maternal mortality rates in nan U.S., and wherever Black women are much than doubly arsenic apt to dice from a pregnancy-related origin than achromatic women.

Former members of Georgia's Maternal Mortality Review Committee person linked nan state's abortion prohibition to delayed emergency care, and nan deaths of astatine slightest 2 women successful nan state, arsenic ProPublica precocious reported.

The personhood proviso is having a profound effect connected aesculapian care, said Atlanta OB-GYN Dr. Zoe Lucier-Julian.

"These laws create an situation of fearfulness and effort to coerce america arsenic providers to align pinch nan state, arsenic opposed to aligning pinch our patients that we activity truthful difficult to serve," said Lucier-Julian.

 Lucier-Julian said that's what happened to Emory Healthcare successful nan lawsuit of Adriana Smith.

But Cole Muzio, president of nan blimpish Christian Frontline Policy Council, says nan state's abortion rule shouldn't impact really Emory handles Smith's care.

"This is simply a beautiful clear-cut case, successful position of really it's defined successful nan connection of H.B. 481. What this bans is an abortion aft a heartbeat is detected. That is nan scope of our law," he said.

"Taking a female disconnected life support is not an abortion. It conscionable isn't," he added. "Now, I americium incredibly grateful that this kid will beryllium calved moreover successful nan midst of tragic circumstances. That is simply a full quality life that will beryllium capable to beryllium lived because of this beautiful mother's sacrifice."

A lawsuit challenging Georgia's rule and its effect connected nationalist wellness is still moving its measurement done nan courts. It was revenge by a conjugation of physicians, nan ACLU of Georgia, Planned Parenthood, nan Center for Reproductive Rights, and different groups.

Smith's mother April Newkirk said her girl had initially gone to a different Atlanta-area infirmary for thief pinch terrible headaches and was sent home, wherever her symptoms quickly worsened.

"She was gasping for aerial successful her sleep, gargling," she told nan station. "More than apt it was blood."

Now, Newkirk said nan family is not judge nan fetus will moreover past nan accent progressive successful months of life support — aliases flight nan risks of terrible disability.

"My grandson whitethorn beryllium blind, whitethorn not beryllium capable to walk, wheelchair-bound, we don't cognize if he'll unrecorded erstwhile she has him," she said.

But she added that nan family will emotion him nary matter what.

This communicative comes from NPR's wellness reporting business with WABE and KFF Health News.