HHS head RFK Jr. is removing all members of a key CDC vaccine policy committee

1 month ago

Health and Human Services head, RFK Jr, is replacing each existent members of CDC vaccine advisory committee. We talk nan imaginable effect connected nationalist wellness policy.

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

In an unprecedented move, caput of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., is replacing each members of nan Advisory Committee connected Immunization Practices, aliases ACIP. It's a committee that plays a cardinal domiciled successful mounting CDC policies astir vaccine schedules and access. The move group disconnected siren bells successful nan nationalist wellness community. So we called Michael Osterholm to explicate nan imaginable effect connected nationalist wellness successful nan U.S. He's nan head of nan Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy astatine nan University of Minnesota. Welcome.

MICHAEL OSTERHOLM: Thank you.

CHANG: So first conscionable show america existent concisely here, what is nan domiciled of nan ACIP? Like, really important is their activity for group trying to make mundane wellness decisions aliases get entree to vaccines?

OSTERHOLM: Well, fto maine first conscionable commencement retired by explaining very concisely really vaccines really travel about. They first person to show that they are safe and effective, and that is simply a reappraisal that is done by nan Food and Drug Administration. But earlier nan existent agency takes connected that decision, they really person different group that they bring successful called VRBPAC, which is for illustration ACIP but it addresses specifically information and effectiveness. Then erstwhile it passes done there, it's moved to nan CDC to this committee called nan Advisory Committee connected Immunization Practices...

CHANG: Right.

OSTERHOLM: ...Which includes 17 experts from astir nan state who person existent expertise successful understanding, really should this vaccine beryllium used? Who's nan groups that it should beryllium recommended for and how? And that is simply a very, very important information because really we salary for vaccines successful this state is tied successful ample portion are they recommended aliases not? So for galore people, if a vaccine is not recommended, moreover though we judge that they could use from it, they will very apt person to salary for that vaccine. And truthful this committee is very important.

CHANG: Do you expect nan CDC's vaccine recommendations will alteration because of these changes to that committee?

OSTERHOLM: Well, 1 of nan things that's happening correct now is we are watching fundamentally what I would see to beryllium complete 60 years of bully nationalist wellness believe virtually thrown retired nan window. And what I mean by that is that we person now, successful a sense, eviscerated each of ACIP successful position of its expertise. Yesterday, each 17 members were fundamentally fired from ACIP, and it's going to beryllium repopulated by individual picks that Mr. Kennedy is going to make.

CHANG: And we don't cognize those picks yet.

OSTERHOLM: And we don't cognize who they are, but fixed his full accent connected reducing vaccine availability, it shouldn't beryllium a astonishment what we mightiness perceive about. And truthful this committee, which successful nan past, has really been a awesome illustration - nan champion of bringing subject believe to nationalist wellness argumentation - is now nary longer there. And nan criticisms that Mr. Kennedy utilized for deciding this - which, by nan way, had ne'er been done earlier successful nan history of nan ACIP making love backmost much than 60 years...

CHANG: You mean removing each 17 members?

OSTERHOLM: Yes, losing each 17 members and person it being done by a individual who has nary existent expertise successful vaccines. You know, he is simply a caput that comes successful arsenic a lawyer, and his closest expertise to vaccines has been nan mis- and disinformation campaigns he is sowing...

CHANG: Well, he has accused nan members - nan existent members of nan ACIP - of having conflicts of interest. I deliberation that's wherever you were going. Do you consciousness location is immoderate merit to that claim?

OSTERHOLM: No, that's - there's nary merit astatine all. And successful fact, fto maine conscionable beryllium really clear. Dating backmost to 2000, erstwhile nan first rumor first came up astir that, location was immoderate issues raised about, did immoderate members person conflicts of interest? In 2009, an inspector general's study came retired saying that location were problems pinch nan process astatine CDC. But it turned retired each of them were - nan papers weren't filled retired correctly, nan incorrect dates aliases nan incorrect accusation was entered successful nan incorrect place. Not 1 of those had thing to do pinch personification having a existent conflict of interest. Since 2009, successful fact, location has been nary examples astatine each - zero - of personification having a conflict of interest, wherever - they each person to beryllium disclosed. You tin spell to nan CDC website correct now and spot each these members' disclosures.

CHANG: OK.

OSTERHOLM: And successful that case, they person to return nan clip that is devoted to a fixed taxable that they person a conflict with, and they cannot participate during that time.

CHANG: Let maine inquire you specifically astir children present because nan CDC recommendations see guidelines for erstwhile adults and kids should person vaccines for communal illnesses. How mightiness this move by Kennedy impact nan vaccine schedule for infants and mini children, specifically, you think?

OSTERHOLM: Well, correct now, children would not beryllium recommended for nan superior bid that - you know, aft their commencement for illustration we person had for nan past respective years. But fto maine conscionable return a measurement backmost and say, erstwhile they talk astir vaccine successful children and not necessary, this past winter, which was not considered portion of nan pandemic, nan existent incidence of terrible illness, hospitalizations and deaths successful children pinch COVID was akin to that we saw pinch influenza. We urge influenza vaccine but not urge COVID vaccines, aliases astatine slightest give...

CHANG: All right.

OSTERHOLM: ...Parents nan action of that.

CHANG: Michael Osterholm is nan head of nan Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy astatine nan University of Minnesota. Thank you.

OSTERHOLM: Thank you very much.

Accuracy and readiness of NPR transcripts whitethorn vary. Transcript matter whitethorn beryllium revised to correct errors aliases lucifer updates to audio. Audio connected npr.org whitethorn beryllium edited aft its original broadcast aliases publication. The charismatic grounds of NPR’s programming is nan audio record.