How one writer quit dieting and discovered her strength through weightlifting

zeljkosantrac/E+/Getty Images

After years spent moving and dieting, Casey Johnston stumbled connected a Reddit station astir weightlifting that transformed her narration pinch her body.

For Johnston, moving was punishing and not peculiarly fun. But she had seen it arsenic a intends to execute nan 1 extremity that consumed her: not being fat.

She had absorbed nan taste connection that nan intent of workout was to make her arsenic mini arsenic possible.

That's why, while scrolling done a weightlifting connection precocious 1 night, Johnston was startled by really group who lifted talked astir exercise.

"I don't assistance to beryllium hot. I assistance to beryllium strong," Johnston recalls 1 devoted powerlifter posting online. She recovered specified a declare bewildering, disingenuous even.

"Liar," Johnston thought to herself.

Some readers mightiness deliberation nan aforesaid astir Johnston erstwhile they first prime up her caller book: A Physical Education: How I Escaped Diet Culture and Gained nan Power of Lifting. After all, isn't hotness nan logic astir group activity out? Johnston readily admits that she was first drawn to weightlifting arsenic different strategy to suffer weight.

But successful her book — portion memoir, portion subject publicity — Johnston makes a captivating lawsuit for why spot training tin connection truthful overmuch more.

She writes movingly of really learning to assistance weights helped her build affectional spot aft leaving an abusive narration and a toxic job. It helped repair her disordered eating and allowed her to bask food.

Most importantly, it changed her cognition astir her ain body, from 1 centered connected denial of pleasance to a narration that now embraces movement, remainder and eating equally.

She discovered, she writes, that "my assemblage could consciousness bully to beryllium in, powerful even. My assemblage could do things."

Johnston said pinch NPR astir her caller book.

This question and reply has been edited for clarity and length.

Casey Johnston, writer of A Physical Education: How I Escaped Diet Culture and Gained nan Power of Lifting Elana Mudd hide caption

toggle caption

Elana Mudd

Why was it truthful difficult for you to judge that nan Reddit poster you constitute astir was motivated by a desire for spot — not attractiveness?

The really short reply is conscionable astir apt internalized misogyny. We can't judge that a female would want anything, truly, different than to beryllium hot.

I wanted to beryllium honorable that my information for getting into lifting was being fixated connected preserving attractiveness, hotness and losing weight. It wasn't like, "I conscionable want to effort this point because it seems fun." No, nan honorable point is that I had tried everything [to suffer weight], and it felt for illustration thing other was working. So beardown is nan impetus to proceed to effort to beryllium arsenic basking arsenic possible, astatine each costs.

I think, hopefully, nan remainder of nan book unpacks nan modulation from 1 to nan different successful arsenic honorable a measurement arsenic possible. I want to fto group know: I'm correct location pinch you.

How did you commencement to deliberation of workout arsenic thing you do for your wellness and well-being, alternatively than to make yourself smaller? And what did you study astir really dieting effects muscle?

I became overweight successful assemblage and wanted to quote-unquote "do thing astir it." And I tried, astatine first, conscionable dieting. I was like, "Great, I'm acold excessively disinterested successful workout to fuss pinch that." Then that didn't get maine each nan measurement to wherever I thought I should be, weightwise. So I started exercising. I started running, hoping to pain calories.

I was moving much and much and eating little and less, but benignant of staying successful nan aforesaid place. I conscionable had nan belief that I should ever beryllium losing weight. I was worried what group would deliberation of me.

And past I learned that what had happened done each of this weight-loss pursuit was that I had dieted and exercised distant each of my thin assemblage mass. I thought my muscles were conscionable location waiting to beryllium uncovered if I mislaid capable weight. And it turned retired that, actually, if you aren't protecting your muscles actively, they tin spell away. Your assemblage will devour them complete time.

I was not alert of this astatine all, truthful I was upset to study that that was nan case. But past I discovered that lifting weights could tally that process successful reverse.

As a superior attraction doctor, I promote my patients to workout because it tin thief cardiovascular health, temper and mobility. But I find that erstwhile I opportunity nan connection "exercise" to my patients, they often perceive "weight loss." Why do you deliberation truthful galore group confuse those 2 terms?

For a agelong time, there's been tremendous unit astir reasoning of those things arsenic nan aforesaid thing. The messaging is starting to alteration conscionable successful nan past fewer years. But moreover a mates of years ago, nan default mode of workout was cardio. The directive of cardio successful celebrated civilization has ever been burning calories, which is astir weight loss.

We've only started to conscionable disentangle them connected a batch of levels. There's much danasiwa coming retired astir nan truth that preserving thin musculus wide is truthful cardinal to preserving our lifestyles and our health, to keeping america moving. Lean musculus wide is connected to metabolism; it's connected to our encephalon activity. Exercise tin person contiguous contributions successful really you consciousness and besides your cardiovascular health.

We're learning overmuch much concretely that nan publication of workout to wellness doesn't travel from weight nonaccomplishment and that weight [gain] is benignant of a downstream effect of a batch of wellness problems.

The societal unit to suffer weight is real. I find that body-positive activists tin beryllium a spot glib astir that sometimes: "Oh, if you conscionable emotion yourself enough, everything will beryllium OK!" That proposal tin ringing hollow. 

I deliberation a batch of times we talk astir societal effects and individual experiences arsenic if they're nan aforesaid thing. The measurement we consciousness astir our bodies is related to capitalism, patriarchy and misogyny. But astatine an individual level, it feels dismissive to say, "Oh, you consciousness that measurement because of capitalism." It's not capable to thief personification genuinely get astatine nan guidelines of what is meaningful to them. Why does their quality consciousness truthful important and threatening to their livelihood aliases goals?

I don't want quality to matter. This is my slightest favourite point to walk clip on. I conscionable consciousness an responsibility to talk astir it alternatively than expanse things nether nan rug. I bring a batch of individual acquisition to it. I was obsessed pinch dieting because of my individual background. It doesn't request to mean that everyone other comes from nan aforesaid place.

I deliberation your individual acquisition of your assemblage matters. If you want to understand much astir really you feel, it's not connected nan outside, but it's connected nan wrong too.

You constitute astir really intimidating gym civilization tin be, particularly erstwhile you started lifting successful 2014. Have things changed astatine all? 

I deliberation for a agelong clip it's been this really benignant of macho, alpha bro-coded thing. It still was erstwhile I started lifting. There was not a batch of contented astir it that was accessible to people. If you wanted to study to lift, pre-smartphone, you had to get a very dense textbook.

Video is truthful enormously adjuvant successful learning to lift. … On nan internet, I was capable to spot a batch of diverseness of group who participated successful lifting that mightiness not needfully beryllium represented successful nan gym I spell to: older people, younger people, women, nonbinary people, group from each walks of life lifting weights. That could each beryllium coming online. I could spot that I don't request to beryllium a bro successful bid to lift.

It has percolated retired into nan culture. Lots of group assistance weights now. They person much consciousness that it doesn't request to beryllium this aggravated characteristic that you return connected successful bid to do it. It tin beryllium nan aforesaid narration a batch of group person pinch running, wherever it's like, "Oh, I'm not a master runner. I'm not moving marathons. I'm conscionable doing it because I bask definite aspects of it."

I emotion that approach. I americium a very casual jogger, which I do because it makes maine consciousness bully and it helps maine sleep, but I don't really person a "runner identity." Can starting lifting beryllium that easy too?

You don't person to return connected nan overwhelming point of, "Oh boy, I'm going to beryllium wholly different if I lift." It tin beryllium super-incremental. Start small. Let nan earthy feedback loop start. Your assemblage is bully astatine building muscle. If you springiness it a chance, pinch these basal elements, I recovered it tin beryllium transformative. … That activity of looking person and listening to yourself is truthful worthy nan time.

You constitute beautifully astir really bully you consciousness erstwhile you commencement lifting. Why does spot training consciousness truthful empowering for you, erstwhile dieting and cardio didn't? 

It's not conscionable astir being smaller. It's astir really you feel. It's astir protecting yourself. You merit immoderate basal functionality of your assemblage and bully feelings of being successful your body. Because you person to beryllium successful your body.

For maine it was ever conscionable like, "Oh, your body, it sucks and it's annoying." It's unspeakable that you person to woody pinch it. It's atrocious to activity out, and you should conscionable ever beryllium minimizing and hating each portion of this.

Lifting brought successful this perspective of A) you don't person to dislike it and B) it tin beryllium a affirmative publication and bully feeling. And not conscionable successful a measurement wherever you consciousness virtuous because you're deprived successful this problematic way.

There's thing to acknowledging really cardinal our bodies are. We each merit to springiness them clip and attention. We're really encouraged from a batch of angles to separate, disconnect, push them speech successful each of these ways, alternatively than salary attraction to really we feel. How does it consciousness to beryllium successful your body?

Mara Gordon is simply a family expert successful Camden, N.J., and a contributor to NPR. She writes nan Substack newsletter Chief Complaint.