Kids who use social media score lower on reading and memory tests, a study shows

Juliana Belo Gutierrez/iStockphoto/Getty Images

Preteens utilizing expanding amounts of societal media execute poorer successful reading, vocabulary and representation tests successful early adolescence compared pinch those who usage nary aliases small societal media.

That's according to a caller study that suggests a nexus betwixt societal media usage and poorer cognition successful teens. The findings are published successful JAMA.

"This is simply a really breathtaking study," says scientist Mitch Prinstein astatine nan University of North Carolina astatine Chapel Hill, who wasn't progressive successful nan caller research.

"It confirms a batch of what we person been proceeding astir from schools each crossed nan country, which is that kids are conscionable having a really difficult clip focusing connected being capable to study arsenic good arsenic they utilized to, because of nan ways successful which societal media has changed their expertise to process information, perhaps."

While astir erstwhile investigation has focused connected nan effect of societal media usage connected kids' intelligence health, "it's captious to understand really societal media usage during schoolhouse hours specifically affects learning, particularly arsenic truthful galore schools are considering telephone bans correct now," says study writer and pediatrician Jason Nagata of nan University of California, San Francisco.

A look astatine reference and memory 

To understand that, Nagata and his colleagues utilized information from 1 of nan largest ongoing studies connected adolescents, called nan Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study. Scientists person been pursuing thousands of preteens arsenic they spell done adolescence to understand nan improvement of their brains.

The ongoing study has been surveying kids astir their societal media usage each twelvemonth and giving them a scope of tests for learning and representation each different year. Nagata and his colleagues utilized information connected complete 6,000 children, ages 9 to 10, arsenic scientists followed them done early adolescence.

They classified nan kids into 3 groups based connected their evolving patterns of societal media use. The biggest group, consisting of astir 58% of nan kids, utilized small aliases nary societal media complete nan adjacent fewer years. The second-largest group, astir 37% of kids, started retired pinch low-level usage of societal media, but by nan clip they turned 13, they were spending astir an hr each time connected societal media.

The remaining 6% of kids — called nan "high expanding societal media group" — were spending astir 3 aliases much hours a time by property 13.

"The dosage effect"

All nan groups were fixed a scope of tests to measurement their cognitive functioning astatine nan commencement of nan study and successful early adolescence. For example, nan oral reference nickname test examined their reference and vocabulary skills. Another test, called nan picture vocabulary test, had them lucifer nan correct pictures to words they heard.

"What was notable really to maine and possibly astonishing was that moreover nan debased [increasing] societal media users, truthful those who had astir 1 hr a time by property 13, did execute connected mean 1 to 2 points little connected nan reference and representation tasks compared to nan non-social media users," says Nagata.

And nan precocious expanding group performed up to 4 to 5 points little than nan non-social media users.

"So those who had nan highest societal media usage person little scores," notes Nagata, "but moreover nan debased users had smaller differences successful their cognitive scores."

"That really speaks to nan dosage effect of these [apps]," says scientist Sheri Madigan astatine nan University of Calgary, who wrote an accompanying editorial for nan study. "It's problematic astatine really precocious uses, but it's besides problematic astatine moreover successful mini doses."

While a quality of a fewer points successful trial scores whitethorn look insignificant, "it's important to understand that kids are a moving target," explains Prinstein, who is besides chief of psychology strategy and integration astatine nan American Psychological Association.

"Even a flimsy alteration successful what they look for illustration aft a short play of clip intends that they're benignant of now pointed connected a trajectory that is different from others. That intends that two, three, 5 years from now, we mightiness beryllium talking astir immoderate very important gaps betwixt kids who mightiness person been dense users aliases not arsenic dense users."

And other caller research shows that hours connected societal media summation later successful adolescence, notes Nagata. "We would expect that erstwhile they deed property 15, 16, 17, their usage will beryllium overmuch higher," which mightiness lead to moreover larger gaps successful cognition and learning successful later years, he adds.

In earlier studies, Nagata's squad has utilized nan aforesaid information from nan ABCD Study and recovered different disturbing trends among underage societal media users.

They found that a mostly of kids — astir two-thirds — commencement utilizing societal media earlier they move 13, pinch nan mean personification having 3 societal media accounts.

They besides recovered high levels of addiction-like symptoms pinch smartphones among 10-to-14-year-olds.

"Half nan kids who had smartphones said that they suffer way of really overmuch clip they're utilizing their phone," says Nagata. "A 4th who are utilizing societal media opportunity they usage societal media to hide astir their problems. And 11% opportunity that societal media usage has negatively affected their schoolwork."

An important clip for encephalon development

Adolescence is simply a captious play for encephalon development, notes Prinstein, erstwhile nan encephalon is fine-tuning its architecture based connected experiences.

"After nan first twelvemonth of life, nan teen play is nan clip wherever we spot nan astir maturation and nan biggest reorganization of nan encephalon successful our lifetimes," he says.

In a recent study, Prinstein and his colleagues recovered that teens who are dense societal media users person brains that are much attuned to an beingness connected societal media, pinch its "rapid, changeless feedback," says Prinstein. "What we're uncovering is that kids go hypersensitive to nan kinds of likes, comments, feedback and rewards they mightiness get from peers."

Those findings thief explicate nan results of nan caller studies, he adds. "It makes cleanable consciousness that if their encephalon is increasing to beryllium optimized for societal media activities, it mightiness not beryllium optimized for different things they request to do, for illustration we saw successful nan [new] study."

The caller study besides "gives america good-enough grounds that we really request to create immoderate policies that are really circumstantial astir creating property limits, for example, connected societal media apps," says Madigan.

Denmark announced past week that it plans to enforce a social media prohibition for users nether property 15, she notes. Australia is requiring societal media companies to "take reasonable steps to forestall Australians nether nan property of 16 from creating aliases keeping an account" starting December 2025.

Madigan hopes different countries will return note. "I deliberation that we'll spot a trickle effect connected that. That's going to beryllium really beneficial for kids."