Parents Give Daughter's Car to Son. Now, They Expect Her to Buy a New One to Drive Them Around

A female turns to nan Reddit organization for proposal pursuing a family conflict complete a car she utilized for 4 years.

In her post, she questions whether she’s successful nan incorrect for refusing to thief her parents pinch proscription aft they gave nan car to her brother.

She explains that she has "maintained and paid nan registration and insurance" connected a car her parents ain "for years.”

Though she acknowledges that nan Jeep Grand Cherokee legally belongs to her parents, she feels she’s much than earned her clip pinch it. She explains that her mom doesn’t thrust and her dada mislaid his licence aft a DUI, truthful she was nan only 1 successful nan location who could usage nan car.

Her dada only had nan car for 3 years earlier his licence was revoked. “It was afloat paid disconnected truthful I conscionable took complete paying for security and registration,” she explains.

The car served her good for 4 years and made it easier to support her parents. “It was bully to person a car for errands and for moving errands for my folks,” she writes, noting that it's "a overmuch nicer car than I would person gotten for myself.”

The business took a move erstwhile her brother, who lives crossed town, started complaining during a caller visit. “He was pissier than accustomed astir maine getting a free car,” she recalls. “He was hollering astir really I’m nan aureate kid and my parents springiness maine everything.”

In response, her begetter decided to return nan car backmost and springiness it to her relative instead. “Like I said it’s not my car and I really don’t request one,” she concedes.

Living conscionable a fewer blocks from her parents and moving from home, she doesn’t trust connected a conveyance for day-to-day needs. “I activity from home. My clients spot maine successful my home,” she explains, noting that her salon is located connected nan main level of her house.

She gets her groceries delivered and astir of her different necessities from Amazon. She besides uses nationalist transit erstwhile necessary. "I don’t request a car aliases nan disbursal of a car," she explains.

However, hostility escalated erstwhile her mom asked for a thrust to a proceeding assistance assignment and was reminded that her girl nary longer had nan car. When her dada later asked erstwhile she planned to bargain a caller one, she "told him I don’t request a car.”

Her begetter expressed interest that she mightiness expect him to bargain her different vehicle. “He said he hoped that I’m not expecting him to bargain maine a car conscionable to tally errands for them,” she writes.

Standing her ground, she offered a compromise. “I said that I would not beryllium getting a car but that if he wants I will divided nan costs of a car stock membership.”

Her dada agreed, reluctantly, but past suggested she screen nan afloat cost. “I reiterated that I do not request a car,” she says firmly. “And that if he keeps it up I won’t moreover divided nan costs pinch him.”

The halfway of nan issue, she suggests, is little astir nan car and much astir fairness and family dynamics. Her brother, now nan proprietor of nan vehicle, reportedly took their mother market shopping erstwhile and made her outcry by treating it arsenic a awesome inconvenience.

“They didn’t want to inquire him for favors,” she shares. “I pointed retired that they could conscionable inquire for nan car backmost but that was besides a non starter.”

Despite her efforts to group boundaries, her begetter accused her of being “ungrate[ful] and childish” for not replacing nan car aft benefiting from it for 4 years. Her response? “I conscionable rotation my eyes now.”

In a little edit to nan post, she clarifies that she’s nary longer paying for nan car’s insurance, though nan registration remains nether her father’s name. She besides admits that she "did usage nan car for individual worldly sometimes," for illustration "getting together pinch girlfriends and going connected dates.”

Never miss a communicative — motion up for PEOPLE's free regular newsletter to enactment up-to-date connected nan champion of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from personage news to compelling quality liking stories.

“I don’t for illustration men knowing wherever I unrecorded earlier I get to cognize them,” she explains.

As nan station concludes, it’s clear she’s not asking for sympathy, conscionable perspective. She’s drawn a line, offered a compromise, and is refusing to beryllium guilted into shouldering a work that nary longer makes consciousness for her. Now, she’s near wondering if opinionated her crushed makes her nan villain.